Macbook 13'; Aluminum Case for Every Day Use?

I posted two you tube case reviews for the macbook 13'; aluminum laptop that are both easily removable.





One is a super hard and water proof case, but is very bulky, and the other one is a soft case with handles that will allow access to all the ports. Both are great cases and each have their strengths and weaknesses, but what would be better for normal everyday use overall as I plan to only use one? (Note that I bought each one on ebay for $20)





Please don't recommend a speck see thru or satin case, as I used both and returned them as they were hard to take off and needed constant cleaning.





Pelican 1080 Case (Hard Case)


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eK8uhRDU鈥?/a>





Radtech Neocase (Neoprene soft case)


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZOTqnCIf鈥?/a>Macbook 13'; Aluminum Case for Every Day Use?
I like hard cases much better, but honestly i didnt like either of those. i like the hard but thin shells, like speck (but im sure some others) makes, and then keeping my macbook in a sleeve as well. If i had to choose one of those, i think i would would choose the hard case, just because the neoprene look like more trouble.